An interesting point was raised on a forum recently regarding the Sony PSP and the financial cost of purchasing one, in comparison to a second-hand laptop which has similar functionality but in a larger package.
I guess this topic arose because the PSP can be an expensive item to purchase, especially if you are looking to either surf the web at home, stream audio over wi-fi, or generally have a high number of homebrew applciations and games on your memory stick.
We can break these costs down as such (in GBP, as at Christmas 2005) :
- PSP: Giga Pack – £280 (including 1GB Memory Stick Duo)
- WiFi Router – £80
- Software Costs – None
Therefore the total to get a PSP up and running with wi-fi enabled in your own home is roughly £360. You could add to this the cost of PSP Games, at around £35 each, PSP accessories such as a protective case at £30, extra Memory Stick Duo 1GB at around £80 etc, but for arguments sake lets say that the cost of purchasing a PSP at Christmas was around £360.
We could also factor in a cost of PC hardware, software and a broadband connection to get your PSP online and filled with homebrew, but as its likely tht few PSP owners would need to go out and buy a PC for this specific purpose, we can overlook it. The only extra PC cost maybe a USB2.0 expansion card, which retail at around £20.
In comparison, a second hand laptop fetching £360 in your local paper is going to be something like a Dell Latitude C- series, with a Pentium 3-M 1.2GHZ, 256 MB Ram, 20 Gigabyte Hard Drive and a DVD-ROM. To this you need to add on the cost of the wireless router to get the laptop online, alternatively reduce that 1.2GHZ CPU to something slower, and the laptop 12 months older to bring its price in line with the PSP Giga Pack.
So, comparing the Laptop to the PSP, what do we have?
Well, the laptop wins on storage capacity, screen size and to a large extent functionality. Where you would struggle to knock out an Excel spreadsheet or Word document on your PSP, the laptop will allow you create your business plan with ease.
Want to watch a DVD, well the laptop will allow you to do that with a decent screen size and sound quality on a par with the PSP standard speakers. But you can watch DVD’s on your PSP. You may need to convert them specifically to the correct format, but I would argue that the playback quality is better on the PSP than on some of the dodgy screens laptops come with.
Where the laptop loses out over the PSP is in games, something which the PSP does incredibly well, and the PSP’s glorious portability. Ever tried to slip a laptop into your pocket?
PSP games, the official ‘comes on a UMD’ variety, all have one great thing in common, they will all work on your PSP. Games on your laptop are even less likely to run properly than games on your PC, and any hope of having them run at a normal (decent) speed with all the fancy graphics turned on should be consigned to the bin the moment you reliase the Pentium 3-M 1.2GHZ chip isn’t designed to allow you to play Medal of Honour with all the bells and whistles.
Of course the laptop will be more than sufficient for playing emulators and its games, but its not quite so easy to balance a laptop on your knees while you are on the bus as it is to pop the PSP out of your pocket and get a quick fix of Metal Slug on the NeoGeoCD emulator. Add into which even with loading the eLoader via GTA, its still quicker to be up and running a game on the PSP than it is to boot up a laptop and begin playing.
Added to which, I’d be less embarressed to use a PSP in public than a laptop, especially if all you want to do is have a quick blast of GTA. Oh, and GTA runs like a dog on my home PC, I can’t imagine trying to play it on a laptop. Of course, if you are a business user who wants to play an occasional game while being able to update your expenses spreadsheet, the laptop is probably the solution for you.